The Club on a Sub vs New York Steamer comparison highlights two very different Firehouse favorites. One leans toward a smoky club sandwich with turkey, ham, and bacon, while the other packs bold deli meats with a tangy twist.
The Club on a Sub is a comforting classic, loaded with smoked turkey breast, Virginia honey ham, crispy bacon, and Monterey Jack cheese, topped with fresh veggies and condiments. On the other hand, the New York Steamer is a deli-style powerhouse featuring pastrami, corned beef, provolone, mustard, mayo, and Italian dressing. For a more complete meal, pair either sandwich with a warm Loaded Potato Soup or a light Side Salad.
| Feature | Club on a Sub | New York Steamer |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor Profile | Smoky and savory with turkey, ham, and bacon. | Bold, tangy, and rich with pastrami and corned beef. |
| Meats | Smoked turkey, Virginia honey ham, bacon | Pastrami, corned beef |
| Cheese | Mild Monterey Jack | Smooth provolone |
| Special Toppings | Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, mustard, pickle | Mayo, mustard, Italian dressing |
| Bread | Served hot on a toasted roll | Served hot on a toasted roll |
| Best For | Fans of classic club flavors with crispy bacon | Deli lovers who enjoy bold, tangy meats |
| Portion Size | Generous, with three meats layered together | Filling, packed with corned beef and pastrami |
| Price Range | Standard Firehouse pricing | Standard Firehouse pricing |
Ingredients
The Club on a Sub combines turkey, ham, bacon, and Monterey Jack cheese with crisp lettuce, tomato, and onion. It’s a reliable option when you want a smoky yet balanced sandwich. The New York Steamer goes bolder with pastrami and corned beef, provolone cheese, and tangy Italian dressing, offering that classic New York deli bite. You can round out either sub with a Hot Ham Combo or try it alongside a fresh Firehouse Salad with Turkey.
Flavor and Texture
Club on a Sub is lighter, with its smoky turkey and ham balanced by crispy bacon and creamy cheese. The New York Steamer, by contrast, is rich and tangy, with the sharpness of mustard and the richness of pastrami and corned beef. Both are toasted hot, ensuring melty cheese and soft bread in every bite.
Portion and Value
Both sandwiches are filling, but the Club on a Sub feels slightly lighter with its turkey base, while the New York Steamer is denser and heavier thanks to its deli meats. To make either meal more affordable, check out deals like the 2 Can Dine for $19.99 Offer or explore Firehouse bundles.
Choosing Your Sub
- Club on a Sub: Best for those who enjoy a smoky, classic club with bacon, turkey, and ham.
- New York Steamer: Perfect if you crave a bold, deli-style sandwich with corned beef and pastrami.
Conclusion
When deciding between Club on a Sub vs New York Steamer, the choice comes down to your taste preference. The Club on a Sub is perfect for a lighter, smoky-sweet combo, while the New York Steamer offers a bold, tangy bite of deli tradition. Both are hot, hearty, and guaranteed to satisfy.
