The Firehouse Meatball vs New York Steamer comparison is a showdown between two hearty subs with very different personalities. The Firehouse Meatball Sub is a comfort-food favorite, loaded with Italian meatballs, marinara sauce, and melted provolone for a saucy, cheesy classic. On the other hand, the New York Steamer delivers deli-style indulgence with corned beef, pastrami, provolone, mustard, mayo, and Italian dressing.
Both are filling and flavorful, but they cater to different cravings—one is saucy and cheesy while the other leans into savory, meaty richness. Pair either with a warm Firehouse Chili Cup or a sweet Firehouse Brownie to complete your meal.
| Feature | Firehouse Meatball | New York Steamer |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor Profile | Saucy, cheesy, and comforting | Savory, smoky, and deli-style |
| Meats | Italian meatballs | Corned beef and pastrami |
| Cheese | Provolone | Provolone |
| Special Toppings | Marinara sauce, Italian seasoning | Mustard, mayo, Italian dressing |
| Bread | Served hot on toasted roll | Served hot on toasted roll |
| Best For | Pasta and pizza lovers | Deli sandwich fans |
| Portion Size | Hearty and saucy | Rich and meaty |
| Price Range | Standard Firehouse pricing | Premium pricing for deli meats |
Ingredients Breakdown
The Firehouse Meatball Sub combines juicy Italian meatballs with marinara, provolone, and Italian herbs—perfect for fans of saucy, cheesy comfort food. The New York Steamer is inspired by classic delis, loaded with corned beef, pastrami, provolone, and a bold mix of mustard, mayo, and Italian dressing. For sides, try the Garlic Bread or the creamy Five Cheese Mac & Cheese.
Flavor and Eating Experience
The Firehouse Meatball sub feels like a warm hug—savory meatballs smothered in marinara and cheese, perfect for Italian-style cravings. The New York Steamer is heavier and more robust, with smoky, salty deli meats and tangy condiments for an authentic New York bite. Each sandwich has a distinct eating experience depending on whether you want cheesy comfort or bold deli richness.
Portion Size and Value
Both subs are hearty, but the New York Steamer feels more premium because of the corned beef and pastrami. The Firehouse Meatball remains a go-to comfort pick, offering excellent value. If you’re looking for deals, the Firehouse Subs $9.99 Meal Deal is a great option to try either with a drink and side.
Choosing Between Them
- Firehouse Meatball: Perfect for those who love saucy, cheesy comfort food with Italian flair.
- New York Steamer: Great for fans of smoky deli meats and bold condiments.
Conclusion
When comparing Firehouse Meatball vs New York Steamer, the choice comes down to flavor preference. If you’re after saucy comfort, the Meatball Sub is unbeatable. But if you want deli-style indulgence with bold flavors, the New York Steamer stands out. Either way, you’re getting a hearty, satisfying Firehouse Subs classic.
